Makes Me Glad I Dropped Out.
Thursday, November 01, 2007 by Michael Reynolds
I'm going to agree about 80% with blogfriend Pastor Jeff, and disagree 20%.
First, agreement:
Ta da!
The person who wrote the document in question needs a long period of unemployment. It is idiotic on its face, and patently racist. The university administration that allowed this stupidity to be forced on students at their school, should be turned out onto the streets and forced to beg for food until they can learn to construct a simple syllogism.
I further agree with Jeff when he writes:
Or, I would add, the GOP, which moved seamlessly during the course of the last 40 years from veiled racism, to veiled sexism, to overt homophobia. There's always a new scapegoat for our Republican friends. But that doesn't counter Jeff's point, merely expands it.
But here, where Jeff contrasts the alive-and-kicking nature of anti-semitism and what he sees as a past-tense racism, I part ways a bit:
I have a one word counter: Katrina.
Am I a Katrina conspiracy nut? No. I don't believe the government opened floodgates hoping to drown black people. But I also don't believe we'd have bought the scare stories of savagery from New Orleans if we'd been talking about white people. And I don't think it would have taken half so long to get men and supplies to the dome if it had been full of white people.
If I may be allowed a small plug for Desert Bayou, a friend's movie (story credit: Me, incidentally,) I don't think 600 white people would have been loaded onto a plane, not told where they were going, flown across the country to, say, Cleveland, (the African-American equivalent of Salt Lake City?) illegally searched upon arrival, publicly accused by the state's highest law enforcement officer of being a bunch of criminals, housed on a military reservation far from the city as opposed to hotels or motels, and then held under curfew.
I don't see that happening to white people.
Racism is very much alive and well. It may have gone underground, but it is far from gone. And yet, I agree that it is overstated, and I agree that focusing on racism as a single-bullet-theory of all the ills of the African-American population is destructive. It's because racism is still so alive that I disagree vehemently with the buffoons running the University of Delaware's little thought-crime indoctrination camp.
Hey, geniuses of Delaware: in the end we want less racism, not more. Right? So you really figure the way to achieve that is to label all whites as racist? Since whites cannot become black, they cannot by your logic ever be anything other than racists, which eliminates entirely the possibility of any progress whatsoever, and ensures that racism will survive in perpetuity.
Seriously, you guys run a college?
Digg This!
First, agreement:
“A RACIST: A racist is one who is both privileged and socialized on the basis of race by a white supremacist (racist) system. The term applies to all white people (i.e., people of European descent) living in the United States, regardless of class, gender, religion, culture or sexuality. By this definition, people of color cannot be racists, because as peoples within the U.S. system, they do not have the power to back up their prejudices, hostilities, or acts of discrimination. (This does not deny the existence of such prejudices, hostilities, acts of rage or discrimination.)"The above is a paragraph from the handbook of the Maoist re-education camp at the University of Delaware. Pastor Jeff thinks the above statements may be just a tad bit false. Just a teeny bit, um, bullshitty. I agree. The above represents circular logic at its finest. If you admit you're a racist, then you're a racist. If you deny you're a racist, you're a racist. If you are white you are ipso facto, a racist, and by the bizarre-o world terms of this document, that categorization of an entire race is not itself racist.
“A NON-RACIST: A non-term. The term was created by whites to deny responsibility for systemic racism, to maintain an aura of innocence in the face of racial oppression, and to shift responsibility for that oppression from whites to people of color (called "blaming the victim"). Responsibility for perpetuating and legitimizing a racist system rests both on those who actively maintain it, and on those who refuse to challenge it. Silence is consent."
Ta da!
The person who wrote the document in question needs a long period of unemployment. It is idiotic on its face, and patently racist. The university administration that allowed this stupidity to be forced on students at their school, should be turned out onto the streets and forced to beg for food until they can learn to construct a simple syllogism.
I further agree with Jeff when he writes:
It's a fascinating (if stomach-turning) look into what becomes of "movements" when they achieve major goals. New issues must be championed; new enemies must be identified; the work has to continually grow -- otherwise, how will the money keep coming in? How will organizers keep their jobs if they can't keep the supporters perpetually outraged about something? Look at what's happened to groups like NAACP or MADD or CSPI or Planned Parenthood.
Or, I would add, the GOP, which moved seamlessly during the course of the last 40 years from veiled racism, to veiled sexism, to overt homophobia. There's always a new scapegoat for our Republican friends. But that doesn't counter Jeff's point, merely expands it.
But here, where Jeff contrasts the alive-and-kicking nature of anti-semitism and what he sees as a past-tense racism, I part ways a bit:
But there really is no significant movement or institutional power which wants to return to Jim Crow, segregation, or slavery. Israelis don't have to go looking for anti-semitism; the rockets are a pretty good reminder. Who is that is actively trying to demean, disenfranchise or destroy black Americans? What actual institutional structures exist to keep black people down? And if you could find any, how would they compare in impact relative to the policies, programs, and laws which do exist to help minorities?
Frankly, I think this racist victimhood mentality is a destructive pathology in American culture. It has no place in a serious academic environment except as a case study of dangerous and bankrupt sociology, like Nazism or communism. I'd prefer such things were consigned to the dustbin of history, only to be studied as examples to be avoided.
I have a one word counter: Katrina.
Am I a Katrina conspiracy nut? No. I don't believe the government opened floodgates hoping to drown black people. But I also don't believe we'd have bought the scare stories of savagery from New Orleans if we'd been talking about white people. And I don't think it would have taken half so long to get men and supplies to the dome if it had been full of white people.
If I may be allowed a small plug for Desert Bayou, a friend's movie (story credit: Me, incidentally,) I don't think 600 white people would have been loaded onto a plane, not told where they were going, flown across the country to, say, Cleveland, (the African-American equivalent of Salt Lake City?) illegally searched upon arrival, publicly accused by the state's highest law enforcement officer of being a bunch of criminals, housed on a military reservation far from the city as opposed to hotels or motels, and then held under curfew.
I don't see that happening to white people.
Racism is very much alive and well. It may have gone underground, but it is far from gone. And yet, I agree that it is overstated, and I agree that focusing on racism as a single-bullet-theory of all the ills of the African-American population is destructive. It's because racism is still so alive that I disagree vehemently with the buffoons running the University of Delaware's little thought-crime indoctrination camp.
Hey, geniuses of Delaware: in the end we want less racism, not more. Right? So you really figure the way to achieve that is to label all whites as racist? Since whites cannot become black, they cannot by your logic ever be anything other than racists, which eliminates entirely the possibility of any progress whatsoever, and ensures that racism will survive in perpetuity.
Seriously, you guys run a college?